Lesson 3 of 7 · 10 min
"Account management" and profit-sharing offers
Why "we trade, you keep 70%" favours the manager even when the trading is honest, what a guaranteed monthly return really implies, and what a legitimate managed account looks like.
By the end you'll be able to
- Show with numbers why a profit share with no loss share rewards the manager for taking risk
- Recognise the signs of an unlicensed account-management offer
- Describe what a legitimate managed account looks like and how to check it
Free course
Enrol in “Protect Yourself: Scams, Signals and Fake Brokers” to start this lesson
Enrolling is free. Your progress, quiz scores and certificate are kept in your account, on every device.
- 7 short lessons with quizzes and interactive tools
- Lesson videos for members
- A certificate when you finish
“Send us $2,000, we trade it, you keep 70% of the profit.” It sounds like a fair split between partners until you ask who pays when the month goes wrong.
The usual path
Stage 1 of 6
The offer
An Instagram page posts monthly “client results” and offers to trade your account: “You keep 70% of profits, we take 30%. 10% a month, guaranteed.”
The check that stops it: Nobody can guarantee a trading return. A fixed monthly figure is a sales line.
Paid in so far: $0
Stage 2 of 6
Handing over control
You are asked to open an account at “our broker” and send the login with the master password, or to send money straight to the manager’s card or crypto wallet. You deposit $2,000.
The check that stops it: Never share a master password. Never send trading money to a person.
Paid in so far: $2,000
Stage 3 of 6
A good first month
The report shows +12%. It may be real trading at high risk, or a number on a platform the manager controls.
The check that stops it: Look at the trade history yourself, not a report. Compare the lot sizes with the balance.
Paid in so far: $2,000
Stage 4 of 6
Top up for a better tier
“Accounts over $5,000 keep 80% of profits.” You add $3,000.
The check that stops it: A new tier that needs more of your money is a deposit request, whatever it is called.
Paid in so far: $5,000
Stage 5 of 6
The bad month
A “market crash” wipes out most of the account, or a withdrawal needs the manager’s “profit share” paid first: $600 in advance.
The check that stops it: A profit share is taken out of profits. Paying it in advance with new money is a warning sign.
Paid in so far: $5,600
Stage 6 of 6
Silence
The page blocks you or changes its name. The managed account, or the platform, is empty.
The check that stops it: Before stage 1 the check was short: is this person licensed to manage other people’s money, and on which register?
Paid in so far: $5,600
A typical path, with illustrative amounts. Tap a stage to see what happens and the check that would have stopped it.
Account management means someone else trades your money. The informal version reaches you through a social media page or a friend and works in one of two ways. Either you open an account in your name and hand over the login with the master password (the one that can place trades), or you send money straight to the manager’s card or wallet. In the second case you own nothing but a promise.
A legitimate managed account looks different. The manager holds a licence to manage other people’s money, listed on a regulator’s register. Your money sits in your own name at a regulated broker or custodian, with a written agreement, fees stated in advance and no guaranteed return. You can see the account and withdraw from it yourself.
Who carries the loss
This works against you even when the trading is real and honest. Add a “guaranteed 10% a month” and the claim fails on arithmetic alone: 1.10 to the power 12 is about 3.14, which would turn $5,000 into roughly $15,700 in a year. Nobody can promise that, and a person who could would not need your $5,000. Returns that arrive at the same rate month after month are a classic sign of a Ponzi scheme, where early investors are paid with later investors’ deposits.
Try it
Tap every line you think is a warning sign.
Warning signs found: 0 of 5
A made-up example. Names, numbers and web addresses are fictional; patterns like these are common in real scams.
The profit split itself is not the warning sign. Watch for what is asked of you: passwords, payments to a person, and decisions before a deadline.
What would you do?
Your cousin says his account manager has paid him 8% every month for five months, and he once withdrew $500 without trouble. He offers to introduce you. What do you do?
Quick check
Quick check
Question 1 of 4
A manager takes 30% of profits and shares no losses. Compared with trading carefully, a reckless approach:
Question 2 of 4
Which password lets someone see your trades without being able to trade?
Question 3 of 4
Returns of exactly 8% every month for five months suggest:
Question 4 of 4
Which of these belongs to a legitimate managed account?
Go deeper: Forex broker scams: 9 red flags and how to check a licence · Segregated accounts in forex · Forex withdrawal: how to get your money out